The title of this blog, The Generalist, sounds a bit like so many TV series at the moment. The Diplomat. The Night Manager. The Good Wife. Those titles are designed to attract immediate interest. They pinpoint exactly what the show is about and carry a sense of authority, almost like this is the definitive version, the one you must watch.
The title I have chosen does not quite land in the same way. It feels more vague, less aspirational, a bit… ‘meh’.
The dictionary definition of a generalist is “a person competent in several different fields or activities.” Which, on the surface, sounds great. But many people instinctively read this as “jack of all trades, master of none”.
When it comes to the human body, though, I believe being a generalist is not only valuable, it is essential.
If we want our bodies to serve us well for as long as possible, generalism is not something to shy away from. It is something to aim for.
And I would strongly reject the “master of none” idea here, because unless you become a happy generalist, you may actually limit your ability to be a master of anything at all.
When specialising starts to backfire
Take my client Matt.
He could not understand why sitting on the floor had suddenly become difficult, or why getting down there, and back up again, no longer felt fluid. He had ongoing niggles in his hips and knees too.
This confused him because Matt is an amateur triathlete. He especially loves road cycling and running. His training was structured, consistent and demanding. He saw weight lifting as the final piece of the puzzle, the strength work that completed the exercise picture.
What he was not thinking about was the range of movement his joints were, or were not, using.
In particular, he was not considering hip rotation, despite the hips being ball and socket joints designed to move in many directions. He was not including balance practice in any meaningful way. And most telling of all, he realised he had no need to get down to the ground in daily life, so he simply never did.
Matt is a great example of someone who thought he was doing everything right, as I once did.
Most of the messaging around exercise focuses on blocks of time at specific intensities. If you tick those boxes, it feels like job done. Tick, tick.
But despite moving a lot, Matt had become a movement specialist. His body was highly adapted, just not in all the ways he needed.
Specialising without realising it
The same thing happens at the other end of the spectrum.
Many people struggle to move as much as they would like. They might get out for a walk a few times a week, but they are busy, tied to a screen for most of the day, and often sitting for far longer than they would ever choose.
Their specialisation simply looks different.
Their bodies become excellent at chair sitting.
Alongside a lack of movement frequency, the same gap exists here too, a lack of movement variety. And it is variety, small, regular, everyday variety, that the body thrives on. It keeps our systems topped up and gives our joints and muscles the mini challenges they need to keep moving well for life.
What the research is starting to show
“Why doing a mix of exercise could be the key to a longer life.”
That was the headline of a BBC News article this week.
It referenced a recent study published in the BMJ last week, by Yang Hu at the Harvard School of Public Health. Researchers tracked the weekly exercise habits of 110,000 men and women in the US over 30 years.
They found that active people who did the greatest variety of exercise were 19 percent less likely to die during that time than those who focused on just one activity. As we already know, the benefits of each type of exercise were still far greater than doing none at all, but variety added an extra layer of protection.
The total amount of exercise still mattered. But the key message was that including a wider range of activities you enjoy can bring greater benefit.
I wholeheartedly welcome this kind of research.
Predictably, the online comments beneath the article suggested we did not need a study to tell us that more exercise improves health outcomes. And I think those comments missed the point.
In a world that celebrates elite specialists, and where time, money and opportunity often limit what we can try, it is very easy to find ourselves specialising without meaning to. Add in the fact that most of us live on autopilot, juggling responsibilities, and it becomes genuinely hard to maintain variety.
What’s still missing from the conversation
What I would argue, though, is that without variety in our everyday movement, we are already missing the foundation that allows us to build resilient, robust bodies in the first place.
As is often the case, this study did not look at how people move across their day, only at structured exercise choices.
The findings are interesting, but I always find myself wanting studies to go one step further.
Because if someone spends most of their day sitting, are they really going to be able to sustain a wide variety of exercise into later life if stiffness, reduced range or pain are already creeping in?
There is a growing body of research on movement frequency, much of which I included in my book. But a combined study looking at both general exercise variety and daily movement variety?
That is the one I would be shouting about from the rooftops.
My bet is that it would show greater independence, confidence and quality of life in the later decades. But I am not holding my breath for that proof just yet.
